Canada
Business and Investment Immigration Overview
Permanent
Residence
Canada
offers the most established and the most widely used investment immigration
programs in the world conferring permanent resident status. Canada accepts
close to six thousand business applicants annually providing permanent
residence to 15,000 immigrants. The Canadian confederation system of
government and the country’ social norms offer a “European
alternative” to the more unabashed capitalism of the USA. Canada
offers European style social benefits complete with the resultant high
levels of taxation and unparalleled quality of life. Under the Canadian
model, business immigrants can enjoy the benefits of a national health
care program, affordable first class education and a national pension
system that provides measurable annual income upon retirement.
Canada’s
constitutional laws feature a dual immigration system. Business immigrants
can therefore choose between a Federal immigration program composed
of the English speaking provinces and a more popular program exclusively
managed by French speaking Quebec. The Quebec immigration program offers
significantly faster processing times and other benefits.
A.
The Investor Program
a.
The Federal Investors Class
The Federal Investor program is passive in nature and requires an investment
of $400,000 CAD which is deposited with the Receiver General of Canada
and a personal net worth of $800,000 CAD with two years of suitable
management or business experience. The investment bears no interest
and must be maintained for five years. Applicants may state a desire
to live anywhere in Canada except Quebec. The investment is government
guaranteed and the proceeds are allocated to the Provinces excluding
Quebec.
The intention is to attract business acumen and investment to Canada.
A qualified applicant has typically owned and/or managed an active trade
or business, which may include professional practices, rather than merely
managing investment activities. In this context gray areas include professionals
that don’t manage the business, passive real estate investors
and investment managers. For example developing real estate may qualify
where as merely owning real estate may not qualify. Gifts and inheritances
only qualify where the applicant parlayed the gift or inheritance into
a business that he or she actively manages.
The regulations require management of five or more full-time employees
or compliance with two of four bright light tests, designed to define
the scale of the underlying business, for at least two years in the
period beginning five years before the date of the application and ending
on the day a determination is made on the application;
* Percentage of ownership in the enterprise times number of full time
employees, not less than two;
* Percentage of ownership times total annual sales not less than $500,000;
* Percentage of ownership times net income not less than $50,000;
* Percentage of ownership times year end net assets not less than $125,000.
The
Federal program permits applicants to finance the bulk of their investment
through designated banking institutions. Typically the financing schemes
require a down payment of $120,000. The bank loans the applicant the
balance of $280,000. The applicant deposits the sum of $400,000 with
the Receiver General. The Canadian government guarantees repayment of
the bank loan not the investor’s down payment.
The
bank takes fees and interest from the down payment, the immigration
agent takes their commissions from the down payment. The Federal government
disburses the net proceeds to the Provinces for use in a variety of
public projects. The net cost to the investor is the down payment. The
five year investment period begins following visa issuance.
b.
The Quebec Immigrant Investor Program
The
Quebec program is virtually the same as the Federal program with the
following important distinctions: the investment is guaranteed by the
Province of Quebec; professionals such as doctors, dentists, accountants
and lawyers do not qualify as management experience; one must state
an intention to settle in Quebec; the investment proceeds are allocated
to the Province of Quebec rather than the English speaking provinces
and the five year investment period begins following Quebec approval,
even before the investor comes to Canada. If the investor is refused
by the Federal authorities for a medical or security inadmissibility,
the investment is refunded.
A
Quebec investor is defined as a foreign national with three years of
management experience in a lawful and profitable agricultural, industrial
or commercial enterprise, in a government body or an international body
and who possesses a personal net worth of $800,000 CAD accumulated through
lawful economic activities. The investor must also undertake to invest
$400,000 CAD for five years, in a prescribed (government guaranteed)
investment.
When
assessing applications, the definition of management experience is strictly
followed and given a narrow interpretation by the Quebec government
authorities. It states:
"The
actual assuming on a full-time basis of responsibilities and duties
related to the planning, managing and control of material, financial
and, where applicable, human resources, provided that such responsibilities
and duties are not assumed in the context of an apprenticeship, training,
or specialisation process attested to by a diploma".
One
may finance the investment in a manner similar to the Federal program
except that the Province of Quebec designates securities brokerage firms
and investment banks to finance the investment rather than banks.
The
Quebec program has been more popular than the Federal program because
they process the applications much faster and pay brokers higher commissions.
It’s that simple. The final result is no different than the Federal
program except that an applicant must land in the Province of Quebec.
But the Canadian Constitution allows Canadian permanent residents to
land in Quebec and move elsewhere later.
Once
approved the Quebec destined applicant will undergo Federal security
and medical background checks prior to visa issuance, which generally
takes place within 3-6 months following Quebec approval.
Some
Useful Hints (Quebec and Federal):
There
is no advantage in investing until one’s application is approved
in principal (either Quebec or Federal).
Processing
delays under the Federal program regularly exceeds 2.5 years. This reduces
the incentive of the Federal program. Rumor has it that the Federal
government wants to increase usage of its program and will reduce processing
delays. But such rumours have come and gone in the past.
The
Quebec program generally offers processing times in the area of 18 months
or less to visa issuance and 12 months to begin the five year investment
period from application submission. Applicants who are able, can attend
their selection interview in Montreal which can further shorten overall
processing time.
As
a result of the above factors, the majority of applicants use the Quebec
program.
Applicants
who require early entry status may consider alternative methods of entering
Canada on a non immigrant basis while waiting for permanent residence
processing to conclude.
Under
the Canadian immigrant investor program, management experienced applicants
may move to Canada for as little as $120,000 CDN. The down payment effectively
becomes the cost of acquiring Canadian permanent residence.
B.
The Entrepreneur Program
a.
The Federal Entrepreneur Class
The Entrepreneur class confers permanent residence upon applicants who
demonstrate an ability to become economically established in Canada
on the basis of their two years of suitable business experience and
a personal net worth of $300,000 CAD. Approval is contingent upon the
entrepreneur undertaking to invest and become involved in the active
management of a qualifying Canadian business operated in Canada that
will contribute to the economy and create employment for Canadians.
There are two important distinctions from the Investors Class. First,
the Entrepreneur Class applicant must establish and become active in
the management of a qualifying Canadian business in Canada. Approved
applicants are therefore admitted to Canada under a conditional visa
and must report regularly to immigration authorities. Applicants who
do not fulfill their qualifying Canadian business conditions may be
subjected to removal hearings which could lead to deportation of the
applicant and family members.
Second, applicants without qualifying business experience cannot qualify.
Thus unlike the Investors Class, the management of five or more full-time
employees option is not available under the Entrepreneur Class.
To
Qualify a successful Entrepreneur Class applicant is one who has:
1. Managed a qualifying business and has controlled a percentage of
equity of the qualifying business for at least two years in the period
beginning five years preceding the application; and
2. Possesses a personal net worth of C$300,000 legally obtained (assets
may comprise of inheritances as well as the assets of a spouse/common-law
partner/same-sex partner) and
3. Undertakes to control at least 33% of the equity of a qualifying
Canadian business and provide active and ongoing management of the qualifying
Canadian business that will create at least one incremental full-time
job (37.5 hours per week or more) for Canadian citizens or permanent
residents, other than the entrepreneur and their family members. This
condition must be fulfilled for a period of one year within the period
of three years after the day on which the entrepreneur becomes a permanent
resident. This is known in the industry as meeting entrepreneurial terms
and conditions.
b.
The Quebec Entrepreneur Program
The
Quebec program differs substantially from the Federal program.
A
Quebec entrepreneur is defined as a foreign national with three years
of management experience in a lawful and profitable agricultural, industrial
or commercial enterprise and who will establish, acquire or participate
in the active management of a lawful and profitable agricultural, industrial
or commercial enterprise that will immediately employ three full-time
residents of Quebec, other than the foreign national and his accompanying
dependants.
To
qualify, an applicant must possess a personal net worth of $300,000
acquired legally, and have sufficient settlement funding to cover the
cost of the applicant’s first three months of living expenses
in Quebec.
Like
Investor applicants, the definition of management experience is strictly
followed and given a narrow interpretation by the Quebec government
authorities.
Unlike
the Federal program, Quebec entrepreneur applicants must successfully
defend a business plan during a selection interview which presented
in general terms, outlines the feasibility and relevancy of the project
to Quebec. The selection interview is typically preceded by a preliminary
market visit to the Province of Quebec by the applicant.
Once
approved, the application proceeds to Federal security and medical verifications
followed by visa issuance with mandatory terms and conditions, within
an overall processing delay which can vary between 18-30 months.
Some
Useful Hints (Quebec and Federal)
Processing
delays under the Federal program regularly exceeds 2.5 years.
Under
the Federal program, applicants who do not own and operate a business
cannot qualify. Therefore, the Quebec program is the only option for
applicants with high level management experience.
The
Quebec program generally offers processing times in the area of 18-24
months to visa issuance.
Under
the Quebec program, applicants who are able, can attend coordinate their
selection interview in Montreal to coincide with their preliminary market
research visit to Quebec. This can further shorten overall processing
time.
Quebec
applicants are under no obligation to carry out their business project
presented during the selection interview. In fact, since the removal
of terms and conditions falls under the Federal domain, applicants can
operate their Canadian qualifying business in any province.
Although
there is no official policy, Quebec authorities seem to give priority
to its Investor applicants and this may explain the longer processing
time for its Entrepreneur case load.
Applicants
who require early entry status may consider alternative methods of entering
Canada on a non immigrant basis while waiting for permanent residence
processing to conclude.
Applicants
who do not plan to remain in Canada on a full-time basis should not
even consider applying under the Entrepreneur program.
C.
The Self Employed Program
a..
The Federal Self Employed Class
The self employed class is geared towards applicants who have relevant
self-employment experience as well as the intention and the ability
to create their own employment and make a significant contribution to
the cultural, artistic or athletic life of Canada, or to create their
own employment by purchasing and managing a farm in Canada.
A successful applicant is one who has at least two years of experience
in the period beginning five years before the date of the application
and ending on the day a determination is made on the application, in
self-employment in cultural activities or in athletics; participation
at a world-class level in cultural activities or athletics; or farm
management experience.
To qualify, the applicant must demonstrate a sufficient financial net
worth which, although somewhat less than an entrepreneur and not specified
in the regulations, should enable the applicant to be self-employed
in Canada and make a significant contribution to specified economic
activities in Canada and to meet the initial settlement requirements
for the applicant and accompanying dependants.
b.
The Quebec Self Employed Program
Self-employed applicants are assessed in Quebec under a point system.
To qualify, the self-employed must have two years of applicable experience,
possess a personal net worth of $100,000, have sufficient settlement
funding and will come to Quebec to create employment for the applicant
by practicing a profession. Successful unmarried applicants must obtain
40 points out of a possible 84 points on pre-selection and 50 points
out of a possible 94 points on selection. Married applicants must obtain
48 points out of a possible 101 points on pre-selection and 58 points
out of a possible 111 points on selection.
2.
Temporary Residence
Applications
for permanent residence under the business immigration program often
entail processing delays that exceed the expectations and objectives
of applicants. Accordingly, alternative solutions promoting early entry,
may be available by way of temporary admissions to Canada though the
investment immigration route.
Canada
admits business immigrants on a temporary basis under the temporary
foreign worker program. Qualified applicants include successful business
persons who qualify for work permits under investment immigration vehicles
supported by applicable International Agreements or that would create
or maintain significant economic benefits or opportunities for Canadian
citizens or permanent residents. The issuance of a work permit on the
basis of investment would depend on the nationality of the applicant
and the nature and location of the business in Canada.
Depending
on the particular circumstances, applicants may undertake dual assessments
of an application for permanent residence and an application for a work
permit.
In
some cases, it may be practical for an applicant to secure a work permit
on behalf of a Canadian business set up as a branch office of an established
entity outside Canada, which a good track record. Once the work permit
is issued the applicant can then submit an application for permanent
residence under a suitable category.